Managers at a recycling firm where a scrap metal worker was killed after suffering head injuries have been convicted of health and safety failings in a case brought by CPS Special Crime Division.
Prosecutions
Recycling firm managers admit safety failings in manslaughter case
By
on 08 March 2022
On 24 July 2017, 35-year-old Stuart Towns died after being struck from above while working at Alutrade Limited’s recycling site in Oldbury.
Alutrade admitted corporate manslaughter. Two company directors and the Health & Safety Manager – Malcolm George, 55, Kevin Pugh, 46, and Mark Redfern, 61, also admitted failing to ensure the health, safety and welfare of the company’s employees at the hearing at Wolverhampton Crown Court.
Ben Southam, of the CPS Special Crime Division, who charged the case, said: “The company had a legal duty to provide a safe system of work to protect their employees from this avoidable serious accident. The CPS case was that their failure to do so caused Stuart’s death.
“These convictions will not bring back Stuart Towns but I hope that they will do something to bring some closure to his family who have waited for this day for so long.”
The court heard how in 2015 HSE sent a Notification of Contravention letter to the company due to the absence of gates on a piece of recycling machinery.
The company installed gates to prevent employees from going under the machine. However, by June 2017 the gates were damaged again and CCTV showed numerous employees, including Stuart, going underneath the machinery while it was still in operation and also climbing in or on the machinery.
Senior managers had been ‘on notice’ about the damaged gates, said the CPS. However, the machinery was not isolated, nor were new gates installed.
The three men will be sentenced on 18 March.
PROSECUTIONS
Company fined £300,000 after surgeons forced to save man’s arm after it is severed by machine
By Thomas Tevlin on 02 September 2026
A clinical waste disposal company has been fined £300,000 after a court heard how surgeons had to spend six hours re-attaching a man’s arm after it was severed below the elbow in an unsafe machine.
Emma Bridgewater fined £266,666 after falling shard of glass injures child
By Belinda Liversedge on 08 July 2026
Ceramics manufacturer Emma Bridgewater has been handed a £266,666 fine after a young girl was injured by falling broken glass during a Christmas lights switch-on event at its premises in Hanley.
HSE fines Esso £1m after ignored corrosion leads to structural collapse
By Belinda Liversedge on 18 June 2026
Esso has been fined £1 million after a major gas leak at Fawley Oil Refinery in Hampshire, following an investigation and subsequent prosecution by the Health & Safety Executive.