Lawyers prepare for gross negligence manslaughter guidelines

By on

New sentencing guidelines for gross negligence manslaughter offences will result in higher jail sentences when they come into force in November, a senior health and safety lawyer has predicted.

Speaking at the Health and Safety Lawyers’ Association’s summer event on 12 July, Dominic Kay QC, said we will see a ‘significant change’ in the average sentences meted out for gross negligence in a workplace context, after guidelines for the first time will give judges a step-by-step approach for sentencing manslaughter offences for health and safety.

“Prosecutors want to pitch cases as high as they can for all sorts of reasons, if that happens in a manslaughter case, [and if the judge decides they are] higher category A culpability cases, then potentially there will be very significant penalties indeed,” he said.

He added that major, upcoming cases could also impact on sentencing for gross negligence manslaughter. “The high profile nature of Hillsborough, Grenfell, Didcot will put manslaughter back into the spotlight,” he said.

The Sentencing Council’s draft guidelines, published in July 2017 for consultation, cover four types of manslaughter; unlawful act manslaughter, manslaughter by reason of loss of control, manslaughter by reason of diminished responsibility and gross negligence manslaughter. This latter is for the work setting, applying to employers who ‘completely disregard the safety of employees’.

Proposals are for judges to use culpability to determine the punishment. There are four levels, from D to A – low (D), medium (C), high (B) and very high (A) culpability – each with different jail term ranges and a new maximum jail term of 18 years.

Judges will for the first time have step-by-step guidelines to consult when sentencing for gross negligence manslaughter cases. Photograph: iStock

The average sentence length in 2014 was four years, which is just the starting point for medium culpability under the draft proposals.

Kay added that from his own analysis of sentences passed from 2008 to 2016, the standard sentence for gross negligence in a workplace context was ‘two years, often suspended’. “The new sentencing guidelines for gross negligence manslaughter will make a significant change,” he said.

The Sentencing Council’s guidelines will be followed by judges sentencing across England and Wales. Guidelines for health and safety offences, corporate manslaughter and food safety and food hygiene offences (Definitive) have been in force since February 2016.

The final guidelines are expected to be published on 31 July and come into force from 1 November:


Crane Collapse MED

Bow crane collapse protest: “Laws must change”

By Belinda Liversedge on 13 July 2020

Safety campaigners are calling for new health and safety legislation after a crane collapsed in Bow, East London killing an 85-year-old woman and seriously injuring a worker.

Asda Geograph 3319012 By Ian SMED

Supermarket workers in landmark equal pay case

By Belinda Liversedge on 13 July 2020

The Supreme Court will decide on one of the UK’s biggest equal pay cases, as lawyers representing more than 43,000 supermarket workers at Asda will insist their work is comparable to more highly paid warehouse workers.

17-The-risks-of-keeping-going_0.jpg (1)

MHF urges for cross-governmental approach to mental health recovery

By Belinda Liversedge on 10 July 2020

The government should draw up a Covid-19 mental health recovery plan and publish a green paper on wellbeing, a new paper has argued.